Rilke & Chamovitz on Plants

A remarkable new book on plants has appeared.  Entitled What a Plant Knows:  A Field Guide to the Senses (NY: Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2012), it is by Daniel Chamovitz, a leading research botanist.  His approach is clever.  He describes at the molecular level how humans sense things, & then does the same with plants.  In doing so, he shows scientific proof that plants can see, smell (yes!), touch (feel) & remember.  He also proves that plants cannot taste or hear.  Regarding the latter, he has fun with a book that appeared in ’73 claiming that plants like the music of Bach & Muzak, but shrink under the impact of Hendrix & Led Zep.  Chamovitz proves that is not true at all, while admitting he grew up on Hendrix & Led Zep.

The book is very well written for the general reader, with only a minimum of jargon.  The endnotes contain all the short scientific articles which appeared in technical scientific journals demonstrating proof of these facts.  But one doesn’t even need to look at those to follow his reasoning.  The book should help cure all those “animal chauvinists” who think plants aren’t intelligent.

The poet Rilke would have loved this book & its wealth of information.  He was always interested in factual scientific precision, hated the approximate in knowledge.  This was especially true of his knowledge of plants.  I illustrate this in chapter 5 of my Rilke on Death book which discusses his intense & unusual interest in several specific plants, notice especially hydrangeas & the hazelnut tree.

In my book  Rilke on Love, I discuss the rose in his self-composed epitaph & also translate this 2-line poem from late in his career:

Transform stamen on stamen,                                                                                                           fill your interior rose.

This is an incredibly concise account of the evolution of the ancient eglantine (sweetbrier) flowers, simple red & yellow, into the more modern rose with its multiple colors, by way of  the eglantine’s stamens slowly evolving into the rose’s petals.  Rilke also refers to this phenomenon in his Sonnets to Orpheus, II, 6.

Read Chamovitz’s fascinating book with Rilke’s approach to plants in mind.




Posted in Rainer Maria Rilke | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Rilke & Chamovitz on Plants

James Joyce on Guns

I used to be into guns but then one day realized what they meant — killing — so I got rid of them.  I have never met a person good enough to have a gun.  James Joyce in his great novel Ulysses has the hero Leopold Bloom think about phrases people use:  “I’ll murder you.  Is it only half fun?” he asks.  I think it often IS only half in fun.

Bloom continues, “Or children playing battle.  Whole earnest.”  People give fake weapons, paintballs & fighting video games to their kids.  The video games cram fighting down kids’ throats.  Even TV ads are ultra-violent, people killing other people.  Yet TV ads show very little sex.  What about equal time?  A kiss for every kick, a realistically simulated orgasm for every realistically simulated killing, a real orgasm for every real killing (& it’s appalling how many of those are shown)?

Then Bloom concludes his rap on guns by asking, “How can people aim guns at each other.  Sometimes they go off.” Yes, indeed, they do go off, accidentally….or deliberately.  I repeat, I’ve never met a person good enough to have a gun.

Posted in James Joyce | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on James Joyce on Guns


Welcome to you who come across my web site.  This blogging is new to me.  I am doing it because I would like to know who comes to my web site & why.  I would also like to share some of my thinking about today’s issues & at least some of the time relate those thoughts to my 2 favorite authors, novelist James Joyce & poet Rainer Maria Rilke.  Of course, I have other interests which I would also like to express occasionally which would not depend on Joyce or Rilke.  For example, I am quite interested in MLB (Major League Baseball), especially my home team the San Diego Padres.  I also thoroughly enjoy classic rock music (’60s to ’80s).  I shall add new tags from time to time, so please come back frequently.  In all cases, I urge you to post your own comments about what I say.  Hope to hear from you.  Thanks!

Posted in Welcome | 1 Comment